It’s Thanksgiving go-time and you’re focused on the main course this year, or maybe you’re bringing dessert to a friend or family’s house for Thanksgiving dinner and want to show up with something that’s sure to impress a crowd. Whatever the reason, with so many incredible desserts available to order either by mail or for pick-up, why slave over the oven? If you are wondering where you can order Thanksgiving desserts you are in luck because we have a list of great options below.
From classic holiday pies like apple, pumpkin, and pecan, to some new desserts your family will want to start making part of your new holiday tradition, check out some of the very best places to order Thanksgiving desserts this holiday season.
Caution: Reading this may cause drooling!
Eilen Berger Bakery
Eilen Berger Bakery is coming out on top again this year with their extensive Thanksgiving dessert options that can be ordered online and shipped right to your home. Two of our favorites include the Chocolate covered praline pecan pie and the Texas hot lava chocolate covered pie. Prices for their Thanksgiving sweets and desserts start at just $27.99 and are guaranteed to impress your guests.
Place an order with the famous Shari’s Berries company offers Thanksgiving sweets ranging from chocolate covered strawberries and pretzels, cookies, fruit baskets, cheesecake bites and more. Serve at your Thanksgiving dinner or take them with you to a Thanksgiving party. Prices start at just $24.99 so Shari’s Berries is perfect for any budget!
Home of Oprah’s favorite red velvet cake, Carousel Cakes is offering all of your favorite cakes, cupcakes and pies this Thanksgiving, including apple pie, pumpkin cheese pie, cherry crumble pie, and of course: classic pecan and pumpkin pie. Thanksgiving pies cost $26.95 plus shipping.
Brownies, anyone? Fairytale Brownies has put an autumn twist on the ho-hum brownie, offering their same delicious recipes in a look perfect for fall. With a wide range of brownie and cookie flavors you are sure to please all of your brownie loving guests. Prices start at $23.00 for small gift boxes.
If you live near a Village Inn you have to try one of their traditional award-winning pies like their classic southern pecan, country apple, or pumpkin with whipped cream, or opt for something more er… “outside the box” this year like strawberry rhubarb, cheesecake, chocolate peanut butter cup, or coconut creme. Prices range from $8.99-$19.99 for the best holiday desserts you can buy, unwrap, and call your own!
My Sugar Pie
Former schoolteacher and My Sugar Pie owner Kelly Maucere is offering up an extensive list of fruit pies available to order by mail this Thanksgiving, including her Mom’s Original” Dutch Apple Pie, traditional apple pie with a lattice crust, blackberry pie, cherry pie with a lattice crust, peach blueberry pie, and more. You can also choose from some of her best sellers, including the Sugar Cream, Hoosier Sugar Pie, pumpkin pie, pecan pie, and chocolate chip “I Love You” pie. Prices for these desserts start at just $23.00
Little Pie Company
Called the “Best mail-order pie in America” by Everyday with Rachael Ray, the Southern Pecan Pie from the Little Pie Company in New York City offers a rich and tender crust, generously balanced pecans and filling, and a scoop of freshly whipped cream. 10-inch pies are $32.00 and they can be shipped directly to you. This year’s pie flavors include old fashioned apple pie, sugarless apple pie, Southern pecan pie, Mississippi mud pie, three berry pie, pumpkin pie, sweet potato pie, salted caramel apple pie
Just in time for Thanksgiving, Marie Callendars has more than 25 pies to choose from this Thanksgiving including more than 25 pies, including apple, banana cream, pumpkin, mince with rum sauce* and “No Sugar Added” apple and Razzleberry®. They also have their new pumpkin cream cheese pie with a gingersnap crust. All pies start at just $13.39.
Voted one of Oprah’s Favorite Things in 2016, Janie’s Cakes bring’s a taste of the old-fashioned, southern made-from-scratch pound cake to your Thanksgiving with the traditional The Plain Jane Pound Cake, or other favorites such as the vanilla, carrot, chocolate lovers, white chocolate and additional options. Prices range from $22 to $40.
The Goode Company is once again offering its’ famous, award winning Brazos bottom pecan pie which is made with farm-fresh eggs and Texas pecans. It ships nationwide for $40. If you want an outstanding pecan pie, give the Goode Company a chance to impress!
A fantastic choice for holiday pies is to order ahead and pick one up from Cracker Barrel. They do not ship pies, but if you are lucky enough to live close you can get all your favorites for just $8.99 including the All-American apple pie, apple pecan streusel pie, chocolate pecan pie, pecan pie and pumpkin pie.